To President Obama, following his key speech on the 'Arab spring' and the US's role in the Middle East
Mr. President
As they always listen to the voice of America’s leaders and people, today the people of Tunisia and all the people of the MENA region have carefully listened to your speech at the State Department, a fitted venue to launch the US new Middle East policy of promoting reform across the region, and supporting transitions to democracy. As usual, you have Mr. President masterfully tackled the issue of democracy for which the Tunisian people and all the people of the MENA country are desperately seeking to embrace. You have delineated how they peacefully stood to decades of dictatorship and suffered from a savage repression and mass killing. I shall add that they are still standing and still suffering from violent repression and counter revolutionary attempts from the remaining of the dictatorships and their attempts to remain at office. People from this part of the world are aware that the road to democracy is paved with all sorts of hurdles, this is the reason why they are desperately seeking a genuine help to achieve the objectives of their peaceful revolutions, for which they have already paid a high tribute. What is emerging from the recent upraises is that that the world cannot go on with an oppressed Arab world. The Arab people are clearly expressing that they want to be part of the modern societies while keeping their cultural characteristics and religious beliefs. They have clearly shown that they overwhelmingly reject all form of terror and primary anti Americanism. Our people value education and know the importance of peace.
They also highly value America’s technical and scientific advances and they want to remind the word that if liberated from dictatorship they can be as many good assets to human kind progress and significantly contribute as they did in the past.
Mr. President we strongly believe that there is a real opportunity here to make Tunisia a laboratory for developing the best democratic model for this part of the world. This is probably a tedious task and a real challenge very much like Hercules twelve labours but definitely worth undertaking. To succeed, such laboratory will need all kinds of support essentially at the economic and social levels and we greet your intention to call the International Monetary Fund and the G-8 summit to help Tunisia recover from the disruption of their democratic upheaval. However, most Tunisians are still afraid to be denied democracy. An action of good will would be for the international community led by the US, to help the Tunisian getting hold of and equitably judging the dictator and his accomplices and mainly retrieve the frozen assets stolen by the former governors. Urgent and fair justice is of paramount importance to Tunisians and would be the best gateway to a successful democratic state. Mr. President, allow me to remind you of the famous American saying “Justice delay is justice denial”.
You have also tackled the issue of terrorism that was and still coupled to this part of the world in the mind of Americans and many others and this is a material for a lot of trauma to most of the innocent Arab and Muslims throughout the world. We formally ask you, now that the war on terror is clearly backed by the Arab populations, to work together on reversing this harmful image largely contributed by former policies and served by an irresponsible press.
You stated Mr. President that the Arab people have achieved more in a short timeframe through peaceful revolution than with decades of terrorism, Let’s just stress that terrorism was carried out by a negligible part of the MENA people and that the vast majority of our people was suffering from state terrorism run by their own dictators leaders. I shall add that the war on terror may not resume soon, as terror is rooted into decades of obscure dictatorship and the most efficient way to uproot terrorism is to uproot dictatorship. We wish to never ever see any kind of support to any potential dictatorship which is the essence for promoting despair and hate.
Regarding the Middle East trickiest issue you have Mr. President pledged to pursue the two-state solution to achieve a durable peace. This is a quite respectable endeavor however we wish to know how the US will proceed to persuade Israel to embrace this solution; and how the US will help building a viable Palestinian state. We believe that peace between Palestinians and Israel is badly needed and it can be achieved only within a frame work of a genuine mutual respect of each party rights and obligations and through a win/win sustainable peace treaty.
On another hand, with regards to the dual and what might seem contradictory attitude of the US toward the Tunisian and Egyptian revolutions and the Bahrain turmoil, you have Mr. president clearly introduced the difference between the different situations and explained US opposition to Iran's intolerance, its illicit nuclear program, and its sponsorship of terror. Within this framework we could add that Bahrain’s problem stems from the fact that Iran is playing a dangerous and politically irresponsible game of promoting communities confrontation and illegitimate interference in the Arab world affairs. Because of Iran’s interferences, the peaceful upraise of a segment of the Bahrain population with its legitimate social demands, that was on the way of a peaceful settlement through dialogue, turned into a violent tentative to overthrow the government.
Mr. President, It is a good time for positive changes and peace, a time for mutual respect and true understanding. The Arab people are ready, this is a historic opportunity and we are looking forward to see the US new foreign policy translate into tangible results.
Prof Dahmani Fathallah
* Tunisian Academic
- Ecrire un commentaire
- Commenter
Indeed, people are more alert and informed today. They aspire to enjoying their basic human rights: live with dignity, access to shelter, education, healthcare, peace and security. Our contribution made to human advancement in the last century has been marginal despite the potential we have. It is probably an opportunity today to unleash this dormant potential and be a major player in various fields of sciences, innovation, art, etc and be a positive contributor to the world. Often, MENA is remembered for terrorism, violence or at best oil! Let's work hard to correct this image and work with those who are trying to genuinely help...
Désolé M.Dahmani. Bien que votre anglais est trés éloquent, la langue choisie n'est pas bien pratiquée chez nous pour bien réagir à votre article . Peut être OBAMA le fera.Merci pour l'effort.
Cher Prof. Dahmani, J'ai apprécié le message adressé par vous meme à Mr. le Président Obama. Certes, clair et compréhensible. Ceux qui ont du mal à comprendre le contenu de votre lettre, elles/ils peuvent améliorer leurs anglais. Comme vous dénoncez l'ingérence de l'Iran au Bahrain, je dénonce notre flagrante ignorance en tant que maghrébins de nos origines amazigh et berbères avant tout. Manque à nos peuples de faire la part des choses: Nous les maghrébins on est arabisé, ce qui diffère à 100% de la notion arabes! Dès qu'on reconnaitra nos origines on avancera; autrement on ira vers la fouille. Cordialement: Eng. B. SAKET
to begin with it may important to note that president obama speech was much addressed this week to the arab world rather than to the american public opinion ;the tunisian revolution which starts the arab spring continue ti inspire people all over the world:this is the second time that president obama praises the courage of the tunisian people his promises to help the transition to democracy is important foo our country :still the most important thing we have to bear in mind that only our unity will save the revolution challenges ahead are serious and need a lot of affords and awareness just keep in mind that as long as we are united as long as success will be in our side
SO TO SPEAK.... This is a perfect example of Obama’s speech amplification. But , there is a gap between will and reality. Democracy needs democrats .The region (Mena) had never experienced democracy during its long and recent history. Therefore, this ideal-goal is to reinvent here. First in heart and mind, in practice, second. Following the Tunisian and Egyptian revolutions, the new era might open a wide door to focus on sustainable values of freedom , equality and happiness. Behind these values, there is a deep and daily behaviour based on conviction.(Learning by doing). On another step, freedom, equality and happiness are common values of human kind. The way to implement them took different corridors which might lead to every where.(…) There is an urgent obligation to establish a road map for a constitutional chapters which include irrevocably at least four rights : Information, Education ,Health and Employment . Duties follow subsequently . As a whole , the arab and the Islamic area dosen’t have a problem ( of hate or love )with the American people .The problem raises when its comes to the Palestinian tragedy and the numerous promises – failures -of the successive US administrations to resolve this political matter which constitute a big shame for the international community ,so to speak .If Washington is committed - per strategic reasons - to the Israeli security , who would pledge for the Palestinian security? Mr. Obama seems to be sincere .This feeling will be applauded by the entire world, if he dare to add that he cares about the Palestinian ( state ) security too.! In fine , It’s a great honor for the small Tunisia to be honoured by the great leadership of the States. But ,a tremendous job is waiting Tunisians and Egyptians to build their democracy and pave the way to freedom and concrete peace.
As long as the position of USA or Obama concerning the palestinian problem is clear and confused with one step ahead and two steps back, we do not trust the american they never helped any democratic process anywhere. we have to stop to ask for the american for any help. Theu never give whithout imposing their interest. we have to build our future by our work and we can do this. In fact this paper is a review of Obama speech without comment and critics
It is important to note that the article concerning Obama's speech on the revolutions going on in the arab world as well as the role of the US in the Middle East, stated neither comments nor critics. The magnificent confidence you have in the US policy to establish durale peace between the Palestinian and Israel, leads us to grasp that the US administration is going to be the Only saviour for the Palestinians. The article shed the light on the fact that Mr Obama should be praised and thanked for this greatly intrevention for Palestinian to gain their peace, which is an unalienable right to them already. Whereas the US has been always working on the side of Isreal and will always be looking for its interests and benefits. So to be objective to the regard of Palestinians, it is quite essential to make Mr Obama grasp the unique conditions of the struggle in Palestine rather than praising the "promises" that we have had enough of them. Palestine bears no resemblance to any other conflict in the modern history thats why their honour will be snatched not given!